Tobacco Packaging Industry: How Standardized Tobacco Packaging Regulations are changing the Global Tobacco Industry

 

Global Tobacco Packaging 

Health Warning Labels Not Enough to Curb Tobacco Use

As research has increasingly shown the severe health impacts of smoking tobacco products, governments around the world have enacted various regulations aimed at reducing consumption. One of the early approaches was requiring health warning labels on cigarette packs detailing the risks. However, studies found these warnings had limited effectiveness as tobacco companies were still able to utilize colorful packaging and branding to appeal to customers. This led many public health advocates and policymakers to argue for more restrictive measures.

Tobacco Packaging Industry Regulations on the Rise

In recent years, many nations have adopted so-called "plain packaging" laws that standardize the appearance of tobacco products down to a drab color with the brand name in a uniform font. Australia was the first country to implement this approach in 2012. Packs could only be sold in a dark brown color with the brand name in a standard small font and at least 75% of the principal display area covered by combined text, symbol and color warnings. Initial research found the regulations were successful in reducing the appeal of smoking and increasing quit attempts.

Australia's landmark legislation helped pave the way for others to follow suit. Several countries in Europe and South America soon adopted similar regulations, including the UK, France, Ireland, Hungary, Norway, Uruguay, and Chile. 

In 2020, Canada mandated plain packaging for all Global Tobacco Packaging products. The implementation of plain packaging is also being considered in other major markets like the United States, India, and China that collectively represent a huge portion of global tobacco consumption.

Industry Pushback and Legal Challenges

Not surprisingly, the tobacco industry strongly opposes plain packaging laws and has fought them through various legal avenues. Branding is crucial to their business model and standardized packaging hampers their ability to differentiate products in the marketplace. Major tobacco manufacturers like Philip Morris International (PMI) and British American Tobacco (BAT) argue plain packaging infringes on intellectual property and trademark rights.

They have launched numerous legal challenges, arguing the regulations violate international trade agreements. PMI sued Australia over its 2012 law but ultimately lost at both the Australian High Court and in international arbitration. Similar cases brought against the UK's regulations were also dismissed. However, the industry continues pursuing litigation options where possible, such as BAT's ongoing challenge against the French regulations at the EU Court of Justice.

Standard Pack Design Considerably Reduces Appeal

Despite the legal battles, research consistently finds plain packaging achieves the public health goal of reducing the appeal and attractiveness of tobacco products, especially to youth. Plain packs diminish the impact of design features, colors and branding that subconsciously encourage positive product associations. Studies show standardized brown packs are viewed as more hazardous, less satisfying and make smokers feel self-conscious in public. This increased "negative stigma" discourages initiation among nonsmokers and increases the salience of health warnings.

However, the industry argues standardized packs could fuel illicit trade by making products more susceptible to counterfeiting without unique branding. While illicit trade is a concern, evidence so far does not suggest plain packaging in itself significantly increases this black market activity, with other factors like tax differentials playing a bigger role. Public health experts counter that the ability to differentiate genuine from counterfeit products should not outweigh the significant health benefits of the regulations.

Global Impact on Trade and Regional Harmonization

As major economies representing over half the world's population have now mandated plain packaging, it presents regulatory challenges for the globalized tobacco industry. Multinational tobacco companies must develop separate pack designs, manufacturing and supply chains for regions with different branding rules. This bifurcation increases costs that likely get passed on to consumers worldwide. There is also incentive for tobacco growers and manufacturers in unregulated nations to supply black markets in regulated territories.

Get more insights on Global Tobacco Packaging